InInshirahislamically integrated self-help
ThemeChoosing your response
ApproachCore
TimeAny
MomentUnder stress
1Volume gets heard as aggression even when it is only urgency. Someone raising their voice is often just trying to be heard.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 17:53

It runs in both directions. When you push your own volume up to make a point land, what arrives at the other person is an attack, and they answer the attack rather than the point. If you notice the sound level climbing on either side, say so plainly and bring yours down first.

Islamic evidence

Tell My servants to say what is best. Satan sows discord among them (Quran 17:53). Discord often begins in how something sounded rather than in what was meant by it.

[Prophet], tell My servants to say what is best. Satan sows discord among them: Satan is a sworn enemy of man

Qur'an 17:53

Psychological evidence

Pooled neuroimaging studies show that deliberately reinterpreting an emotional situation draws on frontal and parietal control regions and lowers activity in the amygdala. Re-reading loudness as urgency instead of attack is that kind of reinterpretation, and it shows up in the brain rather than being merely a nice idea. These were controlled tasks rather than family arguments, so take it as the mechanism and not a promise.

Buhle JT, Silvers JA, Wager TD, Lopez R, Onyemekwu C, Kober H, Weber J, Ochsner KN. (2014). Cerebral cortex (New York, N.Y. : 1991) · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Loudness gets read as intent, so lowering it takes away a threat that was never being sent.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0079-loud-is-not-hostile

Feedback

none yet
On:
2Before you decide someone is having a go at you, go looking for the boring physical explanation. A good deal of the time it is right there.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 15:85

Ears blocked by headphones, a phone about to die, somebody who has not eaten since breakfast. Make the alternative concrete, because a vague thought like maybe she did not mean it will not hold when your chest is tight, whereas she cannot hear how loud she is will.

Islamic evidence

Bear with them graciously (Quran 15:85). Part of grace is leaving room for the explanation you cannot see from where you are standing.

We did not create the heavens and the earth and everything between them without a true purpose: the Hour will certainly come, so [Prophet] bear with them graciously

Qur'an 15:85

Psychological evidence

In an experiment with 121 undergraduates recalling an anger-inducing memory, twenty minutes of reappraisal, distraction or analytical rumination left them with different levels of anger, and rumination was the least helpful of the three. Doing something with the interpretation beats chewing on the event. It was a single session with students, so do not carry the sizes too far.

Denson TF, Moulds ML, Grisham JR. (2012). Behavior therapy · doi

Review detail

Why it works. A specific ordinary explanation can compete with the hostile one, and a vague one cannot.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0080-look-for-the-plain-explanation

Feedback

none yet
On:
3Do not only correct the thought, correct the sentence. Rather than do not shout at me, try can you take those off, I want to talk to you.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 33:70

Telling yourself to stay calm gives you nothing to do, and the ready-made sharp line is still the only thing in your mouth. A plain request gives all that energy somewhere to go. It is also much harder to argue with, so the conversation you actually wanted has a chance of happening.

Islamic evidence

Believers, be mindful of God, speak in a direct fashion and to good purpose (Quran 33:70). Direct and purposeful is set as the standard, which rules out the swallowed version as well as the cutting one.

Believers, be mindful of God, speak in a direct fashion and to good purpose

Qur'an 33:70

Psychological evidence

In a randomised trial of dialectical behaviour informed skills training for borderline personality disorder, what carried the benefit was change in assertive anger rather than in anger that was swallowed or exploded. Saying the thing plainly looks like the useful middle. It was one trial in a particular group, so treat the mediation as suggestive.

Kramer U, Pascual-Leone A, Berthoud L, de Roten Y, Marquet P, Kolly S, Despland JN, Page D. (2016). Clinical psychology & psychotherapy · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Putting a different sentence in works better than trying to hold one back.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0081-ask-instead-of-accuse

Feedback

none yet
On:
4Not taking things personally is a question rather than a personality. The question is short: was that aimed at me, or was I simply standing there?
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 28:55

A lot of what lands on you was already travelling. The bad mood was made at work, or three years ago, or by whoever spoke to them just before you did. Deciding you were in the path of something rather than the target of it takes the sting out without pretending nothing happened.

Islamic evidence

We have our deeds and you have yours (Quran 28:55). A clean line that leaves their behaviour with them and lets you keep walking.

and turn away whenever they hear frivolous talk, saying, ‘We have our deeds and you have yours. Peace be with you! We do not seek the company of ignorant people.’

Qur'an 28:55

Psychological evidence

A meta-analysis of how emotion-regulation strategies relate to each other found that they group into broad families, so the choice is less about one clever technique and more about a general stance of engaging or stepping back. Not taking things personally belongs to that wider stance. It describes how strategies cluster rather than showing what happens when you change one.

Naragon-Gainey K, McMahon TP, Chacko TP. (2017). Psychological bulletin · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Something aimed at you seems to demand a defence, while something you were merely near does not.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0084-was-that-aimed-at-me

Feedback

none yet
On:
5Knowing you have other options and taking one are different things. Somewhere in there is the moment the choice actually gets made, and that moment is what you want to train.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 41:34

Plenty of people can list better responses afterwards and still did the old one at the time. The gap sits somewhere other than knowledge: nobody was awake at the point of selection. Give yourself one physical marker for that point, a hand flat on the table, a step back, a slow breath out, so the moment becomes something you can feel instead of something you spot later.

Islamic evidence

Repel evil with what is better and your enemy will become as close as an old and valued friend (Quran 41:34). The instruction takes for granted that a space exists between what is done to you and what you do next, and puts all its weight on that space.

Good and evil cannot be equal. [Prophet], repel evil with what is better and your enemy will become as close as an old and valued friend

Qur'an 41:34

Psychological evidence

In a seven day diary study, the strategy people reached for depended on how intense the emotion was, so what someone uses when mildly irritated is not what they use when they are badly provoked. That is a good reason not to assume an option rehearsed calmly will be the one selected under heat. Diary reports rest on what people notice and remember about themselves.

Kozubal M, Szuster A, Wielgopolan A. (2023). Frontiers in psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. A choice you can feel yourself arriving at is a choice you can make differently.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0458-the-moment-of-selection

Feedback

none yet
On:
6A new response cannot be laid on top of a cycle that is still turning. Break the circle first, even clumsily, and the room for something else appears.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 28:55

Interrupting looks small and slightly silly: standing up, walking to another room, going quiet mid sentence, putting the phone face down. Interruption is not the fix by itself, but it is what makes a fix possible. Expect to do it many times over, because a circle you have been going round for years does not break on the first go.

Islamic evidence

We have our deeds and you have yours. Peace be with you (Quran 28:55). A clean line and a step away are offered as a proper ending to an exchange, not as running off.

and turn away whenever they hear frivolous talk, saying, ‘We have our deeds and you have yours. Peace be with you! We do not seek the company of ignorant people.’

Qur'an 28:55

Psychological evidence

In a laboratory study, going over an angry episode again and again kept cardiovascular arousal raised across repeated trials, while a competing visual and spatial task cut across the imagery and the physical load that came with it. Interruption was doing something that an intention to calm down was not. It was a short lab task with induced anger, so it demonstrates a small effect rather than a treatment.

McClelland AB, Jones KV, Douglas Gregg ME. (2009). International journal of psychophysiology : official journal of the International Organization of Psychophysiology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Stopping the loop is what creates the gap in which anything else can be chosen.

When not to. If walking out of an argument at home has been used as a weapon before, agree with the other person beforehand what leaving the room means, so it does not land as abandonment.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0461-break-the-circle-first

Feedback

none yet
On:
7You are free in principle and a good deal less free at half past eleven at night in the middle of a row. Freedom is a capacity that rises and falls, which also means it can be built.
CoreChoosing your response5 minutesQur'an 5:8

On autopilot, hijacked, exhausted or drunk, the choice is technically yours and practically not. Knowing that without shame moves the question from what sort of person you are to what state you were in and what could be arranged differently. Sleep, food, distance and not being drunk are unglamorous, and they are most of it.

Islamic evidence

Do not let hatred of others lead you away from justice (Quran 5:8). The warning assumes that strong feeling really can pull your judgement off line, so being fair to someone you dislike takes more than good intentions.

You who believe, be steadfast in your devotion to God and bear witness impartially: do not let hatred of others lead you away from justice, but adhere to justice, for that is closer to awareness of God. Be mindful of God: God is well aware of all that you do

Qur'an 5:8

Psychological evidence

The alcohol myopia account, set out in a review of this literature, holds that alcohol narrows attention onto the loudest provoking cue and away from the reasons to hold back, which is why intoxicated people act on anger they would otherwise contain. It is a theoretical review pulling experimental work together rather than a single study. It describes one particular state, and extending the same narrowing logic to tiredness or stress is a reasonable guess rather than a finding.

Giancola PR, Josephs RA, Parrott DJ, Duke AA. (2010). Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Your capacity to choose depends on the state you are in, and states can be arranged for.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0466-free-in-principle

Feedback

none yet
On:
8To be compelled is to be driven, the way cattle are driven along a road. It makes a quick test in the moment: am I choosing this, or am I being moved?
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 17:53

You can usually feel the difference. Being driven has a narrow, hurried quality, and a righteous certainty that will not tolerate a pause. Choosing can wait a minute without anything terrible happening. Noticing the driven feeling is already a small crack in it.

Islamic evidence

Tell My servants to say what is best. Satan sows discord among them (Quran 17:53). The discord is described as being sown by another hand, which fits the experience of being pushed along by something that does not feel like you.

[Prophet], tell My servants to say what is best. Satan sows discord among them: Satan is a sworn enemy of man

Qur'an 17:53

Psychological evidence

In a randomised experiment, increasing relative activity in the right frontal part of the brain with mild electrical stimulation made people brood more on their anger. That suggests the state a person is in causally shapes whether they get pulled into going over it. It was a small stimulation study in a laboratory, so it supports the general point without saying anything about a real quarrel.

Kelley NJ, Hortensius R, Harmon-Jones E. (2013). Psychological science · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Asking whether you are choosing puts you back in the position of the one who chooses.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0467-driven-or-choosing

Feedback

none yet
On:
9You are free while you are still weighing something up, and once you have chosen you carry that choice until the next one comes round. So the useful thing is to have more of those moments, not to make one perfect decision.
CoreChoosing your response5 minutesQur'an 23:96

Treat a hard evening as a run of small forks rather than one big test you pass or fail. Reply now or in an hour. Say the sentence or leave it. Stay in the kitchen or step outside. Each fork you actually notice hands you the steering for a second, and going the wrong way at one of them is not the end, because another is coming.

Islamic evidence

Repel evil with good (Quran 23:96). It is put as one move to make at the time, and it is there again the next time, and the time after that.

Repel evil with good- We are well aware of what they attribute to Us

Qur'an 23:96

Psychological evidence

In a randomised laboratory experiment, people who recalled an anger provoking event ended up in quite different places depending on how they thought about it, with reinterpreting bringing anger down and going over it keeping anger up. What you do with the memory mattered more than whether it turned up. It was a single session with a recalled event in volunteers, so it is a demonstration rather than a treatment.

Ray RD, Wilhelm FH, Gross JJ. (2008). Journal of personality and social psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. More forks noticed means more chances to go a different way.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0468-more-forks-not-one

Feedback

none yet
On:
10There are two ways to widen the gap between being provoked and responding: get better at noticing, and get better at choosing. They are separate skills, and having both means one can cover for the other.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 25:63

On a good day you catch the heat rising and that alone gives you room. On a bad day you will catch nothing at all, and what saves you then is a response you settled on in advance and can run without thinking. Learn both, and do not read a failure of the first as proof that none of it works.

Islamic evidence

When the foolish address them, reply, 'Peace' (Quran 25:63). A short reply settled on beforehand is precisely the kind of thing that still works on the day you notice nothing.

The servants of the Lord of Mercy are those who walk humbly on the earth, and who, when the foolish address them, reply, ‘Peace’

Qur'an 25:63

Psychological evidence

In a randomised controlled trial with 234 adults whose anger was causing them trouble, short therapist supported internet programmes teaching mindful awareness of emotion, cognitive reappraisal, or both reduced anger, with baseline severity examined as a moderator. Two different routes each helped, and combining them was not clearly better than either alone. The programmes were brief and delivered online, so this says more about direction than about size.

Bjureberg J, Ojala O, Berg A, Edvardsson E, Kolbeinsson Ö, Molander O, Morin E, Nordgren L, Palme K, Särnholm J, Wedin L, Rück C, Gross JJ, Hesser H. (2023). Journal of consulting and clinical psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Two routes to the same gap means one of them failing does not leave you with nothing.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0469-notice-or-choose

Feedback

none yet
On:
11There is no point reasoning with yourself while you are still lit up. Wake the part of you that does the reasoning first, then hand it the problem.
CoreChoosing your response5 minutesQur'an 2:153

Under real arousal the clever reframes you learned are simply not available, which is why they seem to evaporate exactly when they are needed. Something has to come first: slower breathing, cold water on the wrists, standing up, a short walk, a moment of remembrance. Think of it as tapping someone on the shoulder before you ask them a question.

Islamic evidence

Seek help through steadfastness and prayer, for God is with the steadfast (Quran 2:153). Turning to something steadying comes first, and thinking your way through comes after.

You who believe, seek help through steadfastness and prayer, for God is with the steadfast

Qur'an 2:153

Psychological evidence

In an experiment with 200 police recruits, a task that drained self control raised their stated intention to use force in a video scenario, which fits the idea that the deliberate machinery is weakest when demand is highest. It was one experiment with a specific group, and the wider energy account of self control has been contested. Take it as a reason to settle first rather than as a proven mechanism.

Staller MS, Müller M, Christiansen P, Zaiser B, Körner S, Cole JC. (2019). Aggressive behavior · doi

Review detail

Why it works. A tool is no use to a part of you that is not currently switched on.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0501-settle-before-reason

Feedback

none yet
On:
12Aim for the cat rather than the dog. The dog goes off the second the door knocks, while the cat waits, watches, and still moves decisively when it decides to move.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 43:89

Plenty of people hear delay as backing down, and would rather explode than be walked over. Watching an animal that waits without being timid separates the two. Nothing in the pause says you will not act, or that what happened was fine, only that the timing belongs to you.

Islamic evidence

Turn away from them and say, 'Peace': they will come to know (Quran 43:89). Turning away with a word of peace is offered as an ending you have chosen, not as losing.

but turn away from them and say, ‘Peace’: they will come to know

Qur'an 43:89

Psychological evidence

In a randomised trial of skills training informed by dialectical behaviour therapy, what carried the benefit was a shift towards expressing anger directly and assertively rather than either swallowing it or exploding. Assertive is the middle thing the cat is doing. The trial was in people with borderline personality disorder, so the group is specific and the finding concerns the mediating path rather than a rule for everyone.

Kramer U, Pascual-Leone A, Berthoud L, de Roten Y, Marquet P, Kolly S, Despland JN, Page D. (2016). Clinical psychology & psychotherapy · doi

Review detail

Why it works. A pause concedes nothing, it moves the decision to a moment when you can make it.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0504-poised-not-passive

Feedback

none yet
On:
13You are free while you are still deciding. The moment the words leave your mouth you are carrying out an order you gave, and stopping mid sentence is much harder than not starting.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 7:200

This is why everything useful in this work sits early: noticing sooner, waiting before you answer, settling on your line before you knock on the door. After you have committed, most of the effort goes into damage limitation, which is a poor use of the same energy. If you are going to spend attention anywhere, spend it in the seconds before the commitment.

Islamic evidence

If Satan should prompt you to do something, seek refuge with God (Quran 7:200). The turn is placed right at the prompting, before anything has been done, which is where it costs least.

If Satan should prompt you to do something, seek refuge with God- He is all hearing, all knowing

Qur'an 7:200

Psychological evidence

In a randomised laboratory experiment, how people thought about an anger provoking memory decided where they ended up, with reinterpreting bringing anger down and going over it keeping anger going. The handling came before the outcome, rather than the outcome being fixed by the event itself. It was a single session with recalled events in volunteers, so it demonstrates the point rather than proving what happens in a live quarrel.

Ray RD, Wilhelm FH, Gross JJ. (2008). Journal of personality and social psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. The cheapest place to change what happens is before it has started.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0521-before-the-words-leave

Feedback

none yet
On:
14Picture a line of dominoes with a gap where one should be. That gap is what a single pause does: it stops a whole run of things, not only the next sentence out of your mouth.
CoreChoosing your response60 secondsQur'an 41:36

This is why one interruption is worth what it costs you. The angry line you do not say is also the reply you do not get, the evening that does not go bad, the apology you are not writing tomorrow. When a pause feels pointless in the moment, it is usually because you are pricing one act rather than the chain behind it.

Islamic evidence

If a prompting from Satan should stir you, seek refuge with God: He is the All Hearing and the All Knowing (Quran 41:36). The instruction lands at the moment the impulse rises, while it is still only a prompting.

If a prompting from Satan should stir you, seek refuge with God: He is the All Hearing and the All Knowing

Qur'an 41:36

Psychological evidence

Across four experiments, being provoked left people with less capacity for self control on a later task, and brooding on the provocation was one of the routes from being provoked to acting aggressively. This is laboratory work with volunteers rather than a real argument at home. It still fits the ordinary experience of one flare making the next one easier to reach.

Denson TF, Pedersen WC, Friese M, Hahm A, Roberts L. (2011). Personality & social psychology bulletin · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Anger tends to feed the next bit of anger, so breaking the sequence early spares you everything that would have followed.

angerUnder stressscholar review pendinganger-0523-one-pause-stops-a-chain

Feedback

none yet
On: