InInshirahislamically integrated self-help
ThemeEquanimity and perspective
ApproachMindfulness
TimeAny
MomentAfter conflict
1When someone tells the story with every detail, the exact words, the way the door shut, what she was wearing, they are not wandering off the point. The detail is telling you how unsafe it felt.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 6:59

Steering them back to the summary usually lands as being told their experience is a nuisance. Let it run a while and hear the detail as a reading of how frightening it was rather than as a case for the prosecution. You can do this with your own retelling too: notice how sharp the picture still is, and take that as information about fear rather than proof you were wronged.

Islamic evidence

No leaf falls without His knowledge, nor is there a single grain in the darkness of the earth (Quran 6:59). Nothing in someone's account is too small to be worth hearing out.

He has the keys to the unseen: no one knows them but Him. He knows all that is in the land and sea. No leaf falls without His knowledge, nor is there a single grain in the darkness of the earth, or anything, fresh or withered, that is not written in a clear…

Qur'an 6:59

Psychological evidence

In a cross-sectional study, people higher in trait mindfulness reported less anger, hostility and aggression, and lower rumination accounted for part of that link. That points to going over an event as part of what keeps it alive and sharp. Everyone was measured at one point in time, so the direction of the effect is not established.

Borders A, Earleywine M, Jajodia A. (2010). Aggressive behavior · doi

Review detail

Why it works. A frightened body records in fine detail, so the amount of detail tells you how frightening the moment was.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0178-detail-is-the-measure-of-threat

Feedback

none yet
On:
2Those same four dots could have been joined into a cross. You never saw the cross, because the square had already settled.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 3:190

The second step matters more than the first. Not only did you build the picture, you built one of several that fitted the same dots. So when a tone of voice lands as contempt, ask what else those exact facts would fit: tiredness, worry, a bad morning that has nothing to do with you.

Islamic evidence

There truly are signs in the creation of the heavens and earth, and in the alternation of night and day, for those with understanding (Quran 3:190). Looking again at what you have already looked at is treated as the mark of understanding.

There truly are signs in the creation of the heavens and earth, and in the alternation of night and day, for those with understanding

Qur'an 3:190

Psychological evidence

A randomised trial in adults with maladaptive anger tested cognitive reappraisal, the trained habit of generating another reading of a situation, on its own, alongside mindful emotion awareness on its own and the two combined, all delivered briefly over the internet. Producing an alternative interpretation is treated there as a skill to be practised rather than an insight to be had. The programme was brief, which limits the scale of the evidence.

Bjureberg J, Ojala O, Berg A, Edvardsson E, Kolbeinsson Ö, Molander O, Morin E, Nordgren L, Palme K, Särnholm J, Wedin L, Rück C, Gross JJ, Hesser H. (2023). Journal of consulting and clinical psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Once a second reading has been seen to fit the same facts, the first one stops feeling like the only truth.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0774-the-cross-you-did-not-see

Feedback

none yet
On:
3The same cup is a drinking cup at home and contraband in a prison, because the role you are standing in has already decided what you are looking at.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 57:23

You have roles too, and they are quieter than a uniform: the wronged partner, the one who never gets thanked, the employee nobody respects. Standing in one of those, a plain remark arrives pre-interpreted. Working out which role you were in at the time is usually more use than going back over what was said.

Islamic evidence

so you need not grieve for what you miss or gloat over what you gain (Quran 57:23). Standing outside the roles of winner and loser is offered as a way to live, not only as a way to argue.

so you need not grieve for what you miss or gloat over what you gain

Qur'an 57:23

Psychological evidence

Across two different therapies for generalised anxiety disorder, improvement went along with increases in decentering, the ability to see thoughts as passing events rather than facts. Treating your own habitual position as one standpoint among several is that same move. The evidence comes from mechanism analyses inside trials, so it is suggestive rather than settled.

Sarah A. Hayes‐Skelton; Amber Calloway; Lizabeth Roemer; Susan M. Orsillo (2014). Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. The role you are occupying does some of the interpreting before you get any say in it.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0778-roles-hand-you-the-frame

Feedback

none yet
On:
4Think about the last person who shouted at you. Were they angry with you, or were they afraid? The honest answer is usually both, and both is allowed.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 2:155

This is not about excusing anyone. Fear and anger arrive together so often that reading only the anger leaves half of it out. Seeing the frightened part of a person takes the personal sting out of what they said, which leaves you free to answer the situation rather than the insult.

Islamic evidence

We shall certainly test you with fear and hunger (Quran 2:155). Fear is named as something everybody is tested with, including the person raising their voice at you.

We shall certainly test you with fear and hunger, and loss of property, lives, and crops. But [Prophet], give good news to those who are steadfast

Qur'an 2:155

Psychological evidence

A systematic review of loving kindness and compassion meditation across twenty three studies found small improvements in life satisfaction. Practising a warmer reading of other people is a modest general good rather than a dramatic intervention. The studies pooled were varied, so the estimate is rough.

Gu X, Luo W, Zhao X, Chen Y, Zheng Y, Zhou J, Zeng X, Yan L, Chen Y, Zhang X, Lv J, Lang Y, Wang Z, Gao C, Jiang Y, Li R. (2022). Applied psychology. Health and well-being · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Fear underneath somebody's anger makes their behaviour about their state rather than about your worth.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0779-angry-or-frightened-or-both

Feedback

none yet
On:
5You cannot check whether your own view is fair while standing entirely inside it. Being certain you are right is a feeling, and feelings are not evidence.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 22:46

In a row, the sense of being obviously in the right is the thing that gives you permission to hit back. Try holding your version as your version: this is how it looks from here, with what you happened to see and feel. You are not agreeing with them. You are letting a little air in around your own account.

Islamic evidence

It is not people's eyes that are blind, but their hearts within their breasts (Quran 22:46). The blind spot is placed inside us, which is exactly the place we cannot inspect on our own.

Have these people [of Mecca] not travelled through the land with hearts to understand and ears to hear? It is not people’s eyes that are blind, but their hearts within their breasts

Qur'an 22:46

Psychological evidence

Across two different therapies for generalised anxiety, people improved as they got better at decentering, which is seeing thoughts as passing events rather than as facts. It was an analysis of what changed alongside recovery, not proof that the stepping back caused it, and the work was on anxiety rather than anger.

Sarah A. Hayes‐Skelton; Amber Calloway; Lizabeth Roemer; Susan M. Orsillo (2014). Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Anger runs on a verdict, and treating your view as a view rather than a verdict takes the fuel away.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0786-judging-from-inside-your-view

Feedback

none yet
On:
6Their account makes sense from where they are standing. So does yours. Granting the first does not cost you the second.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 6:59

This is the part people refuse, because they hear it as folding. It is not. You can say plainly that from where they sat it looked like that, and still hold your line about what you need. Two coherent views is a starting position for talking, not a surrender.

Islamic evidence

He has the keys to the unseen: no one knows them but Him (Quran 6:59). If the full picture belongs to Him, both of you are working from a part of it.

He has the keys to the unseen: no one knows them but Him. He knows all that is in the land and sea. No leaf falls without His knowledge, nor is there a single grain in the darkness of the earth, or anything, fresh or withered, that is not written in a clear…

Qur'an 6:59

Psychological evidence

In a randomised relapse prevention trial, decentering rose specifically in the group given mindfulness-based cognitive therapy rather than medication or placebo, and it tracked with how well the therapy worked. So the habit of holding a thought at arm's length does look trainable. The finding comes from depression relapse work, so the reach to a disagreement at home is an inference.

Peter Bieling; Lance L. Hawley; Richard T. Bloch; Kathleen Corcoran; Robert D. Levitan; L. Trevor Young (2012). Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. You stop having to win the argument about reality before you can talk about what happens next.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0787-both-views-hold-their-ground

Feedback

none yet
On:
7When someone insults you they are aiming at a description of you: your job, your name, your reputation. The more loosely you hold those, the less of you is standing in the way.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 28:88

Ask who you would be if the description came off. Not as a trick, and not to erase yourself, only to notice that you were never only that word. Some practitioners do a version of this in the room, asking a client who they are and gently declining each answer, which needs care and a reason. On your own, keep it light and keep it short.

Islamic evidence

Everything will perish except His Face (Quran 28:88). What lasts was never the title someone just took aim at.

Do not call out to any other god beside God, for there is no god but Him. Everything will perish except His Face. His is the Judgement and to Him you shall all be brought back

Qur'an 28:88

Psychological evidence

In a randomised trial comparing mindfulness-based cognitive therapy with cognitive therapy for preventing depressive relapse, both prevented relapse, and decentering showed up as a process marker tied to the mindfulness arm. The study was about relapse in depression, not about insults, so the link to what happens when someone takes a swing at you is reasoning rather than a result.

Norman A. S. Farb; Adam K. Anderson; Arun Ravindran; Lance L. Hawley; Julie Irving; Enza Mancuso (2017). Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. An insult can only land on the part of you that you were holding out for judgement.

When not to. If your sense of who you are already feels unsteady, leave this one for a session with someone who knows you rather than trying it alone.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0789-you-are-more-than-the-label

Feedback

none yet
On:
8Being steady about something does not mean you approve of it, and it does not mean you have dropped your claim. It means you have stopped fighting the fact that it happened.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 57:23

People hear acceptance and think they are being asked to say it was alright. Nothing of the sort. You can be perfectly clear that it was wrong and still put down the part of you that keeps insisting it should not have occurred. That second argument is the one that eats the whole day, and it is never won.

Islamic evidence

so you need not grieve for what you miss or gloat over what you gain (Quran 57:23). An even keel is asked for in both directions, not only when things go badly.

so you need not grieve for what you miss or gloat over what you gain

Qur'an 57:23

Psychological evidence

A meta-analytic review found acceptance and mindfulness based treatments improve mental and physical health in chronic pain, with small to moderate effects. What is useful here is that these approaches work on a person's relationship to the pain rather than on removing it, which is the same distinction being drawn. The evidence is from pain rather than from provocation.

Veehof MM, Trompetter HR, Bohlmeijer ET, Schreurs KM. (2016). Cognitive behaviour therapy · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Arguing with what has already happened costs energy you need for what happens next.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0846-steady-is-not-approval

Feedback

none yet
On:
9You can be completely right and still lose the room. Usually the trouble is not the point you are making, it is the edge you are making it with.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective5 minutesQur'an 41:46

Softening how you say something is not conceding it. It is the difference between being heard and being braced against. Listen for the tells in your own delivery: the volume creeping up, the small jab tucked inside a fair sentence, the tone that says you should have known this already. Take those out and the argument survives intact.

Islamic evidence

Whoever does good does it for his own soul and whoever does evil does it against his own soul (Quran 41:46). How you say a thing comes back to you, whatever the merits of what you said.

Whoever does good does it for his own soul and whoever does evil does it against his own soul: your Lord is never unjust to His creatures

Qur'an 41:46

Psychological evidence

In an observational multilevel study, both trait and state mindfulness predicted lower aggressiveness, and anger rumination accounted for part of both paths. Less time spent chewing on a grievance seems to mean less of it coming out at people. The design is observational, so it tells you what goes together rather than what causes what.

Eisenlohr-Moul TA, Peters JR, Pond RS, DeWall CN. (2016). Mindfulness · doi

Review detail

Why it works. People defend themselves against the tone first and never get as far as the content.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0853-right-point-wrong-delivery

Feedback

none yet
On:
10You do not actually know what they are about to say, or why they did it. Swapping the finished sentence in your head for help me understand costs nothing and changes the whole exchange.
MindfulnessEquanimity and perspective60 secondsQur'an 6:59

Finishing people's sentences, deciding in advance what they meant, hearing the insult before it has been made: all of it feels like insight and most of it is invention. Ask instead, and ask plainly. Being asked to explain lowers the other person's guard as well, so you get a better answer along with a truer one.

Islamic evidence

He knows all that is in the land and sea. No leaf falls without His knowledge (Quran 6:59). Complete knowledge of what is going on belongs to God, so the honest move with another person is to ask.

He has the keys to the unseen: no one knows them but Him. He knows all that is in the land and sea. No leaf falls without His knowledge, nor is there a single grain in the darkness of the earth, or anything, fresh or withered, that is not written in a clear…

Qur'an 6:59

Psychological evidence

In a randomised controlled trial, an attention-based treatment drawing on mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and dialectical behaviour therapy reduced aggression and improved anger coping in autistic school-aged children. Where attention is pointed does seem to matter for how anger goes. The trial did not test asking questions, and the participants were children, so treat this as background support rather than a test of the tip.

Clifford P, Gevers C, Jonkman KM, Boer F, Begeer S. (2022). Autism research : official journal of the International Society for Autism Research · doi

Review detail

Why it works. If you assume you know what someone meant, you end up arguing with a version of them you made up.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0861-help-me-understand-instead

Feedback

none yet
On: