InInshirahislamically integrated self-help
ThemePractising under provocation
Time5 minutes
MomentAfter conflict
1A cut heals and you stop thinking about it. An insult has no moment where the body tells you it is over, so it stays available to be replayed for years.
cbtPractising under provocation5 minutesQur'an 42:43

That is worth knowing, because it explains why a remark from a decade ago can still tighten your chest, and why you are not weak for that. The replaying is the part you can work on. Many people find that giving the mind a job that needs the eyes, like walking somewhere unfamiliar or sorting something with your hands, interrupts the loop better than ordering yourself to stop.

Islamic evidence

If a person is patient and forgives, this is one of the greatest things (Quran 42:43). Forgiving is called great partly because nothing else closes the account.

though if a person is patient and forgives, this is one of the greatest things

Qur'an 42:43

Psychological evidence

In a laboratory study, going over an anger provoking memory repeatedly produced cardiovascular arousal that built up across the repetitions, and holding a demanding visual task during the episode reduced that build up. So the replay carries a bodily cost, and occupying the mind can blunt it. This was short term arousal measured in a lab, not a finding about long term health.

McClelland AB, Jones KV, Douglas Gregg ME. (2009). International journal of psychophysiology : official journal of the International Organization of Psychophysiology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Nothing signals the end of a wound to your pride, so the mind keeps reopening it unless you give it somewhere else to be.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0535-insults-outlast-bruises

Feedback

none yet
On:
2Working on anger is not meant to leave you with nothing to say. The aim is to keep the objection and let go of the force it was riding on.
cbtPractising under provocation5 minutesQur'an 16:126

Two things are worth pulling apart: whether something has genuinely gone wrong, and how hot your body has gone about it. A good share of the heat comes from a knock to your standing rather than a threat to your safety, and that is the part that can come down without costing you anything. If the plan is only to swallow it, the grievance sits where it was and tends to come back later, usually louder.

Islamic evidence

If you [believers] have to respond to an attack, make your response proportionate, but it is best to stand fast (Quran 16:126). Responding is not forbidden here. What is held down is the size of it.

If you [believers] have to respond to an attack, make your response proportionate, but it is best to stand fast

Qur'an 16:126

Psychological evidence

In a randomised trial of dialectical behaviour informed skills training for people with borderline personality disorder, the benefit ran through a shift from anger into assertion, and that shift statistically accounted for the improvement. That supports keeping assertion inside the goal rather than aiming only at being calmer. It was one trial in one clinical group, so read it as a direction rather than a settled result.

Kramer U, Pascual-Leone A, Berthoud L, de Roten Y, Marquet P, Kolly S, Despland JN, Page D. (2016). Clinical psychology & psychotherapy · doi

Review detail

Why it works. A complaint said calmly still gets said, so there is nothing left to store up.

When not to. If the anger is about harm that is still happening, the work is not on your delivery but on changing the situation, with help if needed.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0573-keep-the-objection-drop-the-heat

Feedback

none yet
On:
3You can be genuinely indignant and still say the thing evenly. The feeling does not have to travel in your voice.
cbtPractising under provocation5 minutesQur'an 41:34

Notice what actually changes when the heat comes out of it: the words stay, the point stays, the volume and the edge go. It helps to know beforehand what you want the other person to do differently, because that is the part that survives a calm delivery, where vague fury does not. And if you find there is nothing left to say once the heat is gone, that is worth sitting with quietly rather than taking as proof the anger was right.

Islamic evidence

Repel evil with what is better and your enemy will become as close as an old and valued friend (Quran 41:34). The better response is still a response, and it is the one with a future in it.

Good and evil cannot be equal. [Prophet], repel evil with what is better and your enemy will become as close as an old and valued friend

Qur'an 41:34

Psychological evidence

In a randomised trial of 65 adults with aggression problems in their close relationships, an internet delivered programme combining emotion regulation with conflict management practice reduced partner violence, and the mediation analysis supported the regulation part as one route by which it worked. So changing how something is delivered while still having the difficult conversation is a combination that has been tested. The sample was small and people volunteered for it, which limits how far it carries.

Hesser H, Axelsson S, Bäcke V, Engstrand J, Gustafsson T, Holmgren E, Jeppsson U, Pollack M, Nordén K, Rosenqvist D, Andersson G. (2017). Clinical psychology & psychotherapy · doi

Review detail

Why it works. People can hear a request, but they mostly defend themselves against a tone.

angerAfter conflictscholar review pendinganger-0574-say-it-without-the-heat

Feedback

none yet
On: