InInshirahislamically integrated self-help
ThemeWhen anger turns to harm
Time20 minutes
MomentEveryday
1When someone introduces themselves as an abuser, take the word seriously without treating it as the finding. A label names a category of offence, not what is actually going on in them.
CoreWhen anger turns to harm20 minutesQur'an 3:135

Some people arrive with the language of a programme or a court already fitted to them, and it closes down the question of what drives the behaviour before anyone has asked it. Others use the word to punish themselves. Either way, accepting the frame whole means treating the name rather than the mechanism, and you get agreement without change. Ask instead what happens in the few minutes beforehand, and what the behaviour seems to be protecting.

Islamic evidence

Those who remember God and implore forgiveness for their sins if they do something shameful or wrong themselves, and who never knowingly persist in doing wrong (Quran 3:135). The line drawn here is about what a person does and keeps doing, not about the name they carry.

those who remember God and implore forgiveness for their sins if they do something shameful or wrong themselves- who forgives sins but God?- and who never knowingly persist in doing wrong

Qur'an 3:135

Psychological evidence

A meta-analysis of batterer intervention programmes with non-treated comparison groups found effects on domestic violence recidivism that were small and inconsistent across outcome sources. Those are programmes organised around an offence category rather than around any particular mechanism. The finding does not say nothing works, only that grouping people by the label has not delivered much so far.

Cheng SY, Davis M, Jonson-Reid M, Yaeger L. (2021). Trauma, violence & abuse · doi

Review detail

Why it works. You can only change something you have described accurately.

angerEverydayscholar review pendinganger-0243-hold-the-label-loosely

Feedback

none yet
On:
2Some of what a person does to a partner is not defence and not temper. It is a script they watched at home, absorbed as ordinary, and never once held up to the light.
CoreWhen anger turns to harm20 minutesQur'an 4:19

The tell is that it does not feel like a decision. There was no rush of heat and no sense of crossing a line, because at some level this is simply how things go between people. A pattern like that responds to being named and questioned rather than to fear work, and the naming is often most of it: this was the house you grew up in, and it is not the only way a house can be run. Expect grief when it lands, since seeing it clearly usually means seeing what was done to you as well.

Islamic evidence

Live with them in accordance with what is fair and kind (Quran 4:19). The standard set here does not depend on what anyone happened to see modelled at home.

You who believe, it is not lawful for you to inherit women against their will, nor should you treat your wives harshly, hoping to take back some of the bride-gift you gave them, unless they are guilty of something clearly outrageous. Live with them in…

Qur'an 4:19

Psychological evidence

In a randomised prevention trial with 272 Head Start families, combined parent and teacher training reduced conduct problems and promoted social competence in four year olds. Change the adults around a child and what the child takes in changes with them, which is this same mechanism running forwards instead of back. It was early prevention with young children, so it does not directly test undoing a script in a grown adult.

Carolyn Webster‐Stratton; M. Jamila Reid; Mary A. Hammond (2001). Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Something learned as normal stays in place until somebody points at it and calls it what it is.

angerEverydayscholar review pendinganger-0244-script-learned-at-home

Feedback

none yet
On:
3Ask whether the anger is really about this person at all, or whether it is contempt for a whole category of people that happens to have someone standing nearby.
CoreWhen anger turns to harm20 minutesQur'an 16:90

It sounds different once you listen for it. The complaints come out in the plural, about how women are or what wives do, and the particular person in the story keeps vanishing from her own story. Treating that as a relationship difficulty misses it completely, because there is no conflict between two people waiting to be resolved. What has to be met is the belief itself, which is slower work and needs somebody willing to say it out loud.

Islamic evidence

God commands justice, doing good, and generosity towards relatives and He forbids what is shameful, blameworthy, and oppressive (Quran 16:90). Domination itself sits among the forbidden things, not only the temper that carries it out.

God commands justice, doing good, and generosity towards relatives and He forbids what is shameful, blameworthy, and oppressive. He teaches you, so that you may take heed

Qur'an 16:90

Psychological evidence

In a cluster randomised trial across 64 Ethiopian villages, a gender transformative participatory intervention delivered to men, women and couples reduced intimate partner violence. That is evidence that working at the level of what people believe about men and women can change what happens at home. It was one trial in one setting, and how far it travels is an open question.

Sharma V, Leight J, Verani F, Tewolde S, Deyessa N. (2020). PLoS medicine · doi

Review detail

Why it works. If the driver is a view about a whole group of people, nothing that repairs one relationship will touch it.

angerEverydayscholar review pendinganger-0245-contempt-with-a-target

Feedback

none yet
On:
4If the harm has only ever happened when someone had been drinking, the drinking is not the background to an anger problem. It is the anger problem.
CoreWhen anger turns to harm20 minutesQur'an 4:29

Families often know this long before anyone says it aloud: he is fine, except. Go through it honestly, every incident, drunk or sober, and if sobriety has never once produced violence then everything else waits. Years can go into breathing and calming work for a person whose behaviour was never really about how well they calm down.

Islamic evidence

Do not kill each other, for God is merciful to you (Quran 4:29). The people most at risk here are usually the people in the same house, which is why dealing with the drink is itself an act of care towards them.

You who believe, do not wrongfully consume each other’s wealth but trade by mutual consent. Do not kill each other, for God is merciful to you

Qur'an 4:29

Psychological evidence

In a randomised clinical trial, adding a brief motivational alcohol intervention to a batterer programme reduced substance use and violence, and people with alcohol problems had benefited least from the standard programme. A separate experiment that gave alcohol to intimate partners found it shifted the balance of positive and negative behaviour during a conflict task, so the effect on how a disagreement goes is fairly immediate. Neither says drinking explains all violence, only that where it is in the picture it belongs in the plan.

Stuart GL, Shorey RC, Moore TM, Ramsey SE, Kahler CW, O'Farrell TJ, Strong DR, Temple JR, Monti PM. (2013). Addiction (Abingdon, England) · doi

Testa M, Crane CA, Quigley BM, Levitt A, Leonard KE. (2014). Journal of studies on alcohol and drugs · doi

Review detail

Why it works. Treating what actually sets the harm off works faster than treating what merely turns up alongside it.

When not to. If someone becomes dangerous when drunk, the first question is how everyone stays safe tonight, not what treatment to arrange next month.

angerEverydayscholar review pendinganger-0246-only-ever-when-drinking

Feedback

none yet
On: